03 August 2021

What Do You Think You Are?

When Suni Lee won her gold medal in gymnastics at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics, the press touted her as the first Asian American to do so. As the wife of an Asian American, I was curious to see which type of Asian she is.

Reading that Lee is Hmong was confusing. I'd heard of it before, but I wondered where the Hmong people come from. I read that Hmong is an ethnic group found in parts of China, Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, and Myanmar. That's a very large geographic region.

The difference between ethnicity and nationality should be important to genealogists. As shown by the Hmong people, an ethnic group can extend beyond national borders. Likewise, you can have more than one ethnic group within a nation.

Ethnicity is important when reviewing your DNA results. I'm mostly Southern Italian, which is a different ethnicity than Northern Italian. All my traceable roots come from a very small part of Southern Italy. That's why my "community", according to Ancestry DNA, is Campania and Molise—two neighboring regions in Italy.

I looked at the DNA results of my friend (who turned out to be my 6th cousin). Her core ethnicities are Central Ireland and Southern Italian. Her Central Ireland communities are specific to quite a small geographic footprint. Her Southern Italian community is the same as mine.

Remember that your DNA is oblivious to national boundaries.
Remember that your DNA is oblivious to national boundaries.

How do you self-identify? Getting into genealogy has made me identify as Italian more than ever. Yes, I'm American, but my cultural and genetic heritage is Italian. We're an Italian family that happens to live in America and speak English.

Growing up in suburban New York, my classmates were Italian, Irish, Polish, German. I didn't call them American because that was a given. We were all Americans, but Americans are always something else, too. We even called it a nationality (e.g., "What nationality are you?" "I'm Irish.").

Focus on your ethnicity, not your family's country of origin, and your DNA pie chart may make more sense. My pie chart also contains some Greece and Albania, and a bit of Northern Italy. It's clear to me that Greeks, Albanians, and Italians have a shared ethnic origin. People from these areas are very similar. I can imagine we can trace our ancient roots to the same place.

My cousin's adopted daughter has 13% "Germanic Europe" in her DNA profile. Ancestry DNA says this is mostly in Germany and Switzerland, but it reaches into several countries. If you have this ethnicity, but none of your ancestors came from Germany, it would be easy to think this was an error.

She also has 11% Middle East. My first DNA results showed 44% Middle Eastern, which was confusing. But my cousin's daughter's Middle East DNA comes from a specific part of Lebanon. Having Lebanese ethnicity is quite different than the much broader "Middle East". And it's easier to understand.

The best example I've seen of an ethnic group that spans nations is "European Jewish". This ethnicity reaches back to huge amounts of people who had to move from place to place. It's a perfect example of how ethnicity is not tied to nationality.

Ancestry DNA says, "We estimate your ethnicity by comparing your DNA to DNA samples from groups of people whose families have lived for a long time in one place." I can prove my ancestors stayed in their little corner of Italy for centuries. So did their neighbors. This makes us a strong, condensed ethnic group.

So, what do you think you are? I always thought I was Italian and DNA bears me out. Do you belong to an ethnic group that comes from many countries? Did large groups of your distant ancestors migrate from one region to another?

If you have ethnicities that span countries, you may need to adjust your thinking. There's nationality (especially during the Olympics). And then there's ethnicity. Perhaps your roots are deeper ethnically than nationally.

Follow me wherever you like: Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, LinkedIn, or Bloglovin.

Let Me Build Your Italian Family Tree

If you want to find all your Italian ancestors but you need help, let's talk! Find out more at Italian Ancestry Services.

7 comments:

  1. My ethnicity results made more sense to me after my sister's DNA results came in. We found out that we are half-sisters and the daddy that raised us was not my biological father. He apparently is responsible for the Scandinavian(34.2%) and Italian(14.6%) that I never knew I had.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow, your early results must have been a bit shocking to you.

      Delete
    2. Yes, they were shocking all around. Those results, finding out that Daddy wasn't my father, and the accusations that came along with them, nearly cost me my life.

      I just re-read what I had written before and wanted to clarify. When I said "He was responsible for the Scandinavian...", I should have specified my biological father. Sorry for any confusion.

      Delete
  2. I don't do DNA (privacy concerns - companies owning my DNA) - however, as a first generation Canadian, I identify as Canadian, but also as half Polish and half English. Your point about ethnicity crossing borders is important - Poland has existed in many different forms over the centuries, so you will find ethnically Polish people in Germany, Russia, and the Ukraine, among others.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, my late mother-in-law never knew if she should say she was half Polish or half German because "it depends on the year".

      Delete
  3. My genealogy says I'm 75% German (25% northwestern, 25% southwestern, 25% southern) and 25% Irish. My DNA ethnicity estimates are 54% German, 17% Irish, 13% English and northwestern Europe, 9% Norwegian, 4% Scottish and 3% Swedish. I'm thinking the Norwegian and Swedish are actually part of my German ancestry due Viking invasion and colonization, the Scotland and England are part of my Irish ancestry and the northwestern Europe is part of my German ancestry. The problem with part of this theory is that of the 54% German shown, northwestern Germany is a big part of it, which would be the ancestors I would have put as providing some of the Norwegian and Swedish ancestry. The thing is, I have my ancestry documented for most branches back to 3rd great-grandparents and much of it much further back than that. I dont' understand how my DNA would show such a big difference in my ethnicity when I have a paper trail that proves what I believe is my actual ancestry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. DNA is going to stretch back much further. What if a bunch of your 4th great grandparents came from somewhere else?

      Delete